Bruce
Trail Ready!
Posts: 10
|
Post by Bruce on Jun 5, 2024 11:51:17 GMT -8
Hopefully not too many noob questions. I included the context of the trip, short introductory trip, hoping to show wife a new way to spend some time.
_____________________________________
So I've got a short trip planned in a month or so up to Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Two main driving forces for the trip. First off, I've always loved that area and the thought of backpacking in and camping just a few feet from Lake Superior is quite thrilling. The secondary consideration for the trip is, after a few years of watching myself and our three kids take little short, backpacking trips, even if it was just the backyard overnight or to a local state park, my wife has decided she'd like to be included. While the desire to join in I feel is heartfelt, she has just never really been the type of person that would gravitate towards an outdoor activity like that. It's just not in her nature. I have read the great FAQ, and done some searching (but something does seem to be up with the search function) so I hope not to be too much of a pain.
So as I'm prepping for this trip, I'm walking a fine line between giving her gear that will improve her quality of experience, versus not going with what might be a better choice if I knew there was a pretty much guaranteed future in these endeavors. Like at the moment, I'm trying to find a happy medium in getting her a sleeping bag. I could probably go with something with incredible stats and wonderful reviews and a real hefty price tag, versus something that will simply do the job although at the cost of size and weight. The trip I have planned is very short, both in distance and time so I am trying to find equipment that will do the job, but if it ends up not ever being used again by her, I haven't thrown away my retirement savings. As far as distance, the hike from the trailhead to our campsite is a bit over 3 miles. The total length of our stay is probably 48 hours give or take split over three days. The first day will be heading in and setting up camp, maybe doing some light exploring of the immediate area. The next day would be a full day at the campsite, taking side trips up and down the shore with minimal gear to check out the various sites/features, and the third day is packing up and heading back to the trailhead to continue on our vacation. So having a sleeping bag that's a little bulkier and heavier is not a huge problem, obviously lighter and smaller would be better, but again there's a chance that the equipment might never be used again, at least by her. For this trip, I can make choices that I wouldn't make if the itinerary was for a longer/deeper experience.
I'm trying to give the whole family a taste of the backpacking/backcountry camping experience. Already have bags for myself and the kids, a pack, and two tents. I've bought a small cookstove, some cooking gear, a water filtration system, and I still need to pick out different kinds of easy meals to prep, and other smaller details like headlamps, lights, and other incidentals. I'll start listing some of the items I have questions about below, and I may or may not add to the list. Here we go.
As I mentioned, the sleeping bag. I asked her if she had a preference between the traditional rectangular shaped or the mummy shaped, she said she did not want to feel constricted at all, so we're going with the traditional rectangular. If anybody has an idea on one that is just head and shoulders better than others as far as bang for the buck goes, would love to hear your recommendation.
I'm putting a little more thought into the sleeping pad for her, I already have a Big Agnes Air Core Ultra for myself, and I'm thinking a good quality pad might really enhance her comfort. I'm not totally blown away by the performance I've gotten, so I'm not too fearful of getting her something really nice, and if she doesn't end up using it again, I could possibly use it myself, and give myself a possible upgrade.
Cooking fuel. I bought the stove already, (BRS 3000T) but there's such a wide variety of different types of fuels and ingredients that are available out there, is there one that I should be focusing on more than others? I've googled some, but it only added to my confusion.
I plan on picking up a good quality headlamp, as this is something I often use at the house anyways (I already have a cheap one) while working on a car or just about anything where hands-free lighting would be appreciated. But I was also thinking that once it becomes time to head into the tents at night, some kind of a portable and efficient light might be something to have in case we wanted to play cards or whatever. Ideally something that could be used inside the tent stationary and also maybe with a handle on it we could go walking down the trail in the dark if need be with it. Anything come to mind?
Since it is of course a pack and pack out situation, what seems to be the common go to as far as using bags for these purposes, simply getting some decent Ziploc bags? Something a little more rugged, made for just this type of thing?
Is there maybe a company whose meal kits are generally liked? (I'm thinking add the hot water to the bag and stir type deals). I'm sure the kids would be good with Jerky and Ramen, but am hoping to mix it up a bit more.
Hopefully the skeeters and flies leave us alone.
Guess that's enough for now, If anybody has thoughts on any item/category, feel free to chime in. Some may be too vague of a question to give a good answer to, and that's fine. I know how these newbie questions can be. I already have rough ideas on most of this, but thought I'd put this out there, in the thought that someone may have a POV that I hadn't thought of, and might make me rethink something from a better viewpoint, and thus not make a mistake/make a better choice.
Your health is your wealth
Bruce
|
|
|
Post by bluefish on Jun 5, 2024 13:06:01 GMT -8
What's the range of temps likely to be. A cheap quilt in July might be all that's needed. My wife and I use a lightweight blanket. Do you really need something below a 40 degree rating in July? Don't count on bugs being gracious, be prepared. The sleeping pad is key, unless, like my wife, she is basically narcoleptic and thinks granite is comfortable. I've liked some of the Packit Gourmet meals, Mountain House has some fairly edible entrees. If you can sneak in one real meal that's one pot it might be a hit. I make Idahoan potatoes and add corn, packaged chicken or smoked salmon, Bacon bits, peas etc. Tasty, filling and a little better than most freeze dried. It's also quick. Peanut butter and hazelnut spread, or whatever you like, on tortillas is a good lunch. Cheese sticks are good for their weight, too. 3 miles isn't a long hike , especially in a non-mountainous area, splurge a little and your wife will thank you. For many years, I've used LUCI lights for our tent, they're solar powered and will even charge a phone with the newer models. Might be worth looking into. I've hiked at night with them. They're not a floodlight, but they work. I've always found MSR fuel canisters to be reliable, but in summer, most will be just fine, even the coleman cheapies in wallie world. You don't need to worry about winter mixes.
|
|
|
Post by downriver on Jun 5, 2024 14:35:11 GMT -8
Have you thought of renting her gear from REI? REI use to rent gear. It might be a good way to go and see if she really likes the outdoors before you go and buy her new gear in case she doesn’t like the outdoor experience.
Have a great trip…!
Regards,
DR
|
|
zeke
Trail Wise!
Peekaboo slot 2023
Posts: 9,997
|
Post by zeke on Jun 5, 2024 14:53:46 GMT -8
Not knowing your budget, I'll attempt to help. LUCI lites are the real deal. Never had the ones that will recharge other gear, but the plain ones are great. A good pad will do wonders for any sleeping experience. Splurge. If your budget allows, think about a down quilt instead of a sleeping bag. They allow for more freedom from that confined feeling. UGQ or Enlightened Equipment offer several choices. Take a treat for everyone. Many parents use M&Ms for the kids, or their favorite snack. A good dark chocolate for your spouse, or her preference.Hand it over when you have some quiet time together. Meals can be commercial freeze dried. I like most everything, but Mt House Biscuits and gravy is a decent b-fast. So does oatmeal and dried fruit. Chili Mac, Beef stroganoff, or Chicken and dumplings are my favorite dinners. Lunches can be pb&J, or pulled pork from meat shredz. Simple crackers and cheese works also. Baby Bells work well in warm weather.
|
|
swiftdream
Trail Wise!
the Great Southwest Unbound
Posts: 655
|
Post by swiftdream on Jun 5, 2024 15:01:17 GMT -8
I wouldn’t worry much about isopro fuel as every brand I’ve used has performed well, Snow Peak, MSR, Jetboil, Olicamp, Gas One, etc. A windscreen is the one thing that will make any stove be most efficient but you don’t want to enclose the canister of a top stove like the model you have. There are some third party offerings that will fit the stove, won’t overheat the canister and possibly make it blow.
Other than that I agree with Downriver to see if you can rent gear for your first time backpacker to see what they like and if they will like backpacking. It’s always an adventure so have a great trip.
|
|
trinity
Trail Wise!
Posts: 3,012
Member is Online
|
Post by trinity on Jun 5, 2024 16:15:35 GMT -8
downriver 's suggestion to rent, if possible, is a very good one. My wife and I camped in the Porkies in July a few years ago. The mosquitoes were fierce. Be prepared. Agree with others that pad is where you want to splurge. For maximum comfort, I like Big Agnes and Nemo. Get a 25" wide pad. which greatly increases comfort for a small weight penalty. If you decide to purchase, I would definitely go with a quilt. Hammock Gear and Jacks R Better have some economical options. For summer camping in the upper midwest, a 40 degree quilt (or bag) should work. I would recommend a 60" wide quilt. As others have said, brand of fuel canister shouldn't matter much. That is a pretty minimalist stove, especially if cooking for 5. I think it would be worth adding a stove, either another BRS 3000 (since they are quite inexpensive), or something more robust and reliable, such as an MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe, Soto Windmaster, etc. My favorite backpacking food brands are Stowaway Gourmet, Packit Gourmet, Pinnacle Foods, and Mary Jane's Farm. These meals are quite expensive, but worth it, in my opinion. Stowaway Gourmet is definitely my favorite overall brand. I'm also a fan of Luci Lights. For a headlamp, I light the Nitecore NU25, though there are lots of great headlamps out there. Another great light is the Rovyvon Aurora A5. Tiny, bright, rechargeable, and can clip to a ballcap to function light a headlamp.
|
|
rebeccad
Trail Wise!
Writing like a maniac
Posts: 12,895
|
Post by rebeccad on Jun 5, 2024 17:34:23 GMT -8
Some good advice here. I will recommend reading the pinned thread in this gear section that addresses lots of basic gear questions. The Women’s forum might address some questions she may have, or may not know yet she has ![:)](//storage.proboards.com/forum/images/smiley/smiley.png) Maybe let her browse around there. There is so much good info in the food section, but I’m a huge fan of the add-hot-water approach (though I make my own). When looking at the commercial meals take a look at serving sizes—I find the calorie counts vary wildly. I like the Mango Rice and Chicken (something like that) from PeakFuel, and I had a good sweet pulled pork I think was also from them. I usually end up wanting about 1.5 servings, but some here will tell you I have a healthy appetite ![:)](//storage.proboards.com/forum/images/smiley/smiley.png) As for hauling out your trash, most of us don’t carry in a trash bag, but collect trash in the used bag from cooking/eating the first meal. You want to keep trash to a minimum anyway. For packing out TP, each person needs a zip-lock in a discreet cloth bag or something. I’m hoping campsites right by the lake have outhouses, which would make that a non-issue. I have never carried more than a single pot; I used to manage for the 4 of us with a 1.8L pot, but our kids were light eaters. For 5 you are apt to need more like a 2.5L, if you want to be able to fix 5 meals and maybe some hot drinks in one go. Or just plan on boiling twice, which keeps the pot smaller and lighter and probably isn’t that much less efficient.
|
|
daveg
Trail Wise!
Michigan
Posts: 569
|
Post by daveg on Jun 5, 2024 20:20:52 GMT -8
I have backpacked Pictured Rocks. It is a beautiful location for an introductory trip. If you don't mind me asking, what backcountry campsite do you have reservations for?
While the views from the trails looking out over the lake are great, they are not the same as the views from a boat looking inland toward the cliffs. Don't know if a boat tour from Munising is in your plans. If not, I would highly recommend it.
It sounds like you are driving. If you are going up the central or eastern part of the lower peninsula, you will be passing within 25 miles of my house. I have a wide variety of backpacking gear and, if you want, you can borrow what you need for your wife. (But I don't have a 25" wide sleeping pad; just 20" pads). PM me if you're interested.
Adding to what others have already said:
Be prepared for the stable flies. They have a bad bite and are particularly fond of legs and ankles. Insect repellent doesn't keep them away. Whether they will be a bother depends on the weather. I always take long pants, thick socks, and a long sleeve shirt just in case.
I haven't stayed at all the backcountry campsites, but I believe all of them have privies. But bring your own toilet paper. The campsites I have stayed at do not have picnic tables -- just logs to sit on. If you want more lounging around comfort, you may want to consider taking a hammock or chair. (I don't have a lightweight backpacking chair either).
|
|
|
Post by bluefish on Jun 6, 2024 3:01:55 GMT -8
I think you hit the jackpot with daveg. One thing I haven't seen mentioned is raingear. Doesn't have to be great, but it could make it a lot more pleasant if it does get a little wet. I always carry a 9'x7' tarp and some guylines if I'm going to expect rain and there's trees to attach to. I don't know how many times I've been thankful for it to cook under, or just get a break from the tent. Hopefully, you get a dry spell and all that is unnecessary.
|
|
ErnieW
Trail Wise!
I want to backpack
Posts: 10,518
Member is Online
|
Post by ErnieW on Jun 6, 2024 4:41:18 GMT -8
My first bit of advice would be make sure you wife isn't cold overnight particularly her feet. A rectangular bag may not do that. Quilt or bag with a good foot box. Next I would considering having a car camping or maybe even hotel plan if the weather is going to be horrible. It might be the wisest choice if you are trying to convince her camping is fun. Talk to her before you go about going to the bathroom (unless she already knows the deal). Listen if she has any concerns and explain how it will work on this trip. If she has to go to the latrine during the night go with her unless she insists otherwise. Lots of snacks and no cook food besides the cook ones. Easier for everyone. She can also help feed the kids which is likely part of her home routine. I'm guessing you'll be doing the cooking. If she is a reader bring a book (or ebooks and a charger pack). She might really like you taking the kids for a little day trip and kick back in the camp's hammock and read.
P.S. How old are your kids?
|
|
ErnieW
Trail Wise!
I want to backpack
Posts: 10,518
Member is Online
|
Post by ErnieW on Jun 6, 2024 5:01:50 GMT -8
I haven't stayed at all the backcountry campsites daveg how is overnight food storage handled at these sites?
|
|
daveg
Trail Wise!
Michigan
Posts: 569
|
Post by daveg on Jun 6, 2024 6:41:20 GMT -8
I haven't stayed at all the backcountry campsites daveg how is overnight food storage handled at these sites? The campsites I have stayed at had bear lockers. But they are communal. If another camper does not close the door properly, food is not protected. That happened to me once and a rodent got in and feasted on my GORP. Fortunately, it left my other food alone. And I was wrong about all the backcountry campsites having privies. Several do not. See the Pictured Rocks Backcountry Planner.
|
|
jazzmom
Trail Wise!
a.k.a. TigerFan
Posts: 3,139
|
Post by jazzmom on Jun 6, 2024 9:03:31 GMT -8
You've gotten a lot of advice, so I'll try not to pile on too much, but from the perspective of a woman who lives in Michigan...
- I think buying used gear is a good option. Backpackinglight.com has a good gear swap forum. The site members are crazy gearheads, so the stuff they sell are generally high end/high quality items. The big issue for you is that you don't have a lot of time before your hike.
- Pay attention to her pack. In the past, packs were non-gender-specific which just meant that they were designed for men. The best part of packs designed for women (IMO) are the hipbelts designed for our waist-hip shape. The hipbelt is what transfers the weight of the pack to your legs/core (instead of on your shoulders) and a woman's strength is more concentrated in her lower-core (as opposed to upper body), so that hipbelt fit really matters. (Note that women typically wear their hipbelts higher than men.) And since a woman's pack weight is often a bigger percentage of her bodyweight than a man's, it's easy for an ill-fitting pack to ruin the hike.
- Just my opinion but I don't know that pads are as critical for women as it seems to be for the guys. Probably because we're typically smaller/lighter and don't displace as much air/volume, plus the displacement is more evenly spread out. I was OK on a closed-cell foam mat until my 50's. (I used to think it was an age thing but I think there was a weight impact as well.) If anything, I would think about the R-value (insulating capability) of the pad more, especially if you're considering a quilt.
- There are a lot of people who are intimidated by the idea of being constricted in a mummy bag, and people who like quilts swear by them BUT I think there's a "learning curve" to using quilts. In general, women sleep colder and, if you dislike drafts, there's some skill involved in using a quilt. If there's any concern there, I would recommend a mummy bag with a full zipper. It can be opened up and used like a quilt and is also a little wider so that it provides fuller coverage without drafts.
- Make sure you take enough toilet paper. Yes, experienced women backpackers have found alternatives but, in general, we need toilet paper every. single. time. I can't remember whether the backcountry toilets at Pictured Rocks have toilet paper but I always pack on the assumption that they don't. I also always assume that I'll carry out used toilet paper. I like doggy poop bags for this - they're super light and, well, I think it's a plus that you can't see thru them.
- Don't leave bug protection to "hope". Make sure you take something like DEET. And I've heard that the ticks are especially bad this year.
|
|
Bruce
Trail Ready!
Posts: 10
|
Post by Bruce on Jun 6, 2024 9:16:45 GMT -8
Hi everyone, first off, wow! Thank you for all the responses, a lot of really good stuff in there, things I never even thought about. A lot of it that was mentioned was things I had thought about, but you didn't know that and they are all really solid pieces of advice.
I'll go through the responses as they came in, I'll try to keep it all in one post. If someone responded more than once, I'll probably respond to their suggestions all at once also.
I just wanted to thank you all again for the responses, I was hopeful for maybe a couple insights, but I am truly overwhelmed. And if there's something that's been left unsaid, feel free to keep them coming!
Bluefish - the expected temperature range for when I plan on being there is highs in the low to mid 70's, lows overnight down to the low 50s. Should be good sleeping temps, weather permitting.
I've seen mentions here and there as I've been digging into this about people using a quilt, but for some reason I naturally filtered that information out, I have absolutely no idea why. I guess the notion of camping to me has always simply been all about "a backpack, a tent, and a sleeping bag" just overwhelmed my thought process. But I am thoroughly intrigued with the idea, and I'm hoping to get a few more details on the application and process of using one. My first question is, what do you use as a barrier between the sleeper and the pad? If I was to make a switch myself, I'm picturing myself as I sleep, I'm not a big pajama guy, I would probably be in boxers laying on top of a very plastic feeling air mattress. Would it be best with a mattress/pad made out of a different material? Should one also pack along a sheet or some other kind of covering if their pad is of similar material? Do you simply tuck part of the quilt underneath? I'm probably overthinking the logistics here, but that's what's going through my mind. I really like the idea of a quilt, just trying to figure out all the ins and outs.
Your food choices sound really good and really interesting, and probably something I would try eventually. But for this trip, I'm trying to keep it as simple and foolproof as possible for myself and my wife. I could see a packaged meal of some sort, but for the kids your idea of the various spreads on a tortilla sounds like a really good idea. They like that already, so that's kind of a no-brainer.
I'm in the process of narrowing down my lighting options, I appreciate your suggestions, and will definitely look at those also.
As I read all the replies, I saw many responses about different brands of fuel, and how they're pretty much all the same. My confusion was actually not about the brands, but about the ingredients. I've seen mentions of pressurized canister versus liquid. Some of the options include propane, butane, isobutane, or blends of a variety of those. Was wondering if either or any are clear cut favorites, or whether they're all pretty much the same and will do the job, so it's a personal preference kind of thing. The liquids that I saw mentioned included, kerosene, unleaded petrol, alcohol...... I didn't give them much thought.
The possibility of having some bad weather has occurred to me, I'll respond to that a little further down when it gets brought up in more detail.
Downriver - I have mulled over in my mind possibly renting, but the biggest expense I was looking at was a really good pad, and if it turns out there is no further interest from my wife, I would probably adopt it to replace the one I have. The actual sleeping bag or quilt I would probably go with would be much less of an expense, and it might be pretty much the same price as renting, so at least at the moment I'm not looking at that as an option. But it is a great suggestion.
Zeke - I'm presently looking into various lights, and the LUCI are very much in the mix. I'm totally on board with the good pad, I know when I added one to my sleeping ensemble it made a world of difference. Back in my 20s the ground wasn't a problem. Not so much anymore. I already mentioned my interest in a quilt, I did have some questions about the application that I posted above. The idea of a treat for all is a great idea, I will for sure try to work that in.
Swiftdream - if you could expand a little bit on what you mean about not being able to use a windscreen on the type of stove I've got, I'd like to hear it. I was thinking at the very least I could bring along some aluminum foil that I could manipulate into a screen of some sort if the winds were really whipping on any of the days that we're there.
Trinity - Yes, the mosquitoes and black flies or stable flies or whatever they are are very much on my mind. Certain times of the year are more vulnerable to them, including the time I'm planning. I've heard that if there's a decent wind coming off the lake that usually keeps them at bay, hoping for the best. Having everybody wear long sleeved, long pants and thick socks was part of the plan, or at least have them available if need be. The weather being in the low 70s makes dressing like that not too uncomfortable.
Yeah, a really good pad is definitely on my list. As I mentioned before, I'll be looking for something at least 25 inches wide, and once again, any insight on how to rig the sleeping arrangement using a quilt would be appreciated. I went into details with my questions above.
As far as the stove goes, yes, it is very small and lightweight, truth be told I really expect only myself and my wife to possibly give it any use, I think the kids will opt for different meal options that they have a preference for which does not include heating. And I appreciate the suggestions on different brands of food to look into, looking over my options. And I see another vote for the LUCI lights!
Rebeccad - great suggestion about looking into the women's forum, something I definitely didn't even think about.
As far as the trash issue goes, for some reason I was picturing a central bag to hold and deposit all the smaller trash of bags into. I'm having a hard time picturing a bunch of little bags from individual meals, being loosely placed in one part of a backpack or something? Maybe I am misunderstanding something.
At the campsite I am at it does have two outhouses in place, from what I can tell the best options along the whole trail. The instructions say to bring your own TP, but at least we don't have to worry about disposing of it.
I'm not picturing us needing large quantities of hot water, but on the chance we do, I guess we'll just have to temporarily eat in shifts, which you also alluded to with "boiling twice."
Daveg - I don't mind you asking at all, I've got campsite five at the Chapel Beach location. Chapel Rock really made an impression on us during the cruise, and we are really looking forward to seeing it up close. The whole Chapel Loop trail looks wonderful, hope to explore as much of it as we can.
Great suggestion on the cruise, I recommend it also. The wife and I actually took that three or four years ago, we took the sunset cruise and it was gorgeous.
Yes, we are driving. I have vacationed off and on my entire life at Houghton Lake, (I grew up in Toledo) and have gone just about every year for the past 10 years, and will be doing that this year again. We love getting out of the heat down here during the worst of it. It sounds like you might be in that general area, where are you located? I appreciate the offer of loaning me some gear, at the moment I don't think I need to take advantage of it, but very gracious of you and thank you again.
ErnieW - as you and others have mentioned, the weather of course is a wildcard and could totally change plans. The plan I presently have is if bad weather seems pretty inevitable, we're just gonna forgo the trip this year. Our follow on was visiting my wife's family in the Windsor Ontario area, so we would simply head straight there from our vacation spot in Middle Michigan. I already have a reservation for the night before our hike at a motel in Munising, I guess it's possible we could still head up and check out a few sites, Tahquamenom Falls, Whitefish Point, etc. But if the weather is bad enough to cancel the camping trip, I might want to forgo those options as well.
The kids are 15, 13 and 11, two boys and a girl, the girl being the youngest.
Thank you all for the wonderful suggestions, certainly has given me new options to consider, and those look to only enhance the experience!
A quilt, heh, never thought of that.....
Your health is your wealth
Bruce
|
|
|
Post by Coolkat on Jun 6, 2024 9:19:19 GMT -8
So I've got a short trip planned in a month or so up to Pictured Rocks National Lakeshore in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Have you been there recently? You should know that the NPS has fully taken over the park from the state and it now has entrance fees like all other National Parks. If you're backcountry camping I hope you already have your reservations. Long gone are the days of being able to show up and get permits the same day. If you're car camping at 12 Mile or Hurricane River you will also need to have permits before you go. As you cannot just drive in and claim a spot. ALL SPOTS are reservation only. I don't think they'll even do reservations at the rangers station (if they are open). And unless they've put up more towers the cell service is very spotty and you can not call RECREATION.GOV from campsites. You'll need to drive east or west at least 15 miles to get a cell signal. I'm assuming that you've already have your reservations in. However, if not PM me and I can give you a few tips of where to camp near by. I've got campsite five at the Chapel Beach location. Chapel Rock really made an impression on us during the cruise, and we are really looking forward to seeing it up close. The whole Chapel Loop trail looks wonderful, hope to explore as much of it as we can. This answered my concern. Looks like you have permits already and are set to go. Campsite #5?? That is the best one in my opinion at Chapel Beach. Its the furthest back and more private. Even if you don't do the whole Chapel loop make sure you get up on top of Grand Portal.. the views are just incredible. One last thought, when I was there last fall they still had warning sign up for the drive back to Chapel loop trail head that a high clearance vehicle is suggested.
|
|